Twitter is demoting certain accounts so terrible people have less presence on the site
This could get tricky quickly.
Gizmodo believes Twitter is using a new ranking behavior to bury several prominent far-right accounts from the service’s search results. In some instances, these accounts no longer appear in the social platform’s drop-down results, or when searching either for their display names or @ handles. The move follows Twitter’s decision announced in May to demote the reach of “troll-like behavior.”
On Saturday, Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey sent out a tweet asking users what type of content should be banned or at least curtailed from the service. He noted,
Fundamentally, we need to focus more on the conversational dynamics within Twitter. We haven’t paid enough consistent attention here. Better organization, more context, helping to identify credibility, ease of use. Challenging work and would love to hear your thoughts and ideas.
Fundamentally, we need to focus more on the conversational dynamics within Twitter. We haven’t paid enough consistent attention here. Better organization, more context, helping to identify credibility, ease of use.
Challenging work and would love to hear your thoughts and ideas.
— jack (@jack) July 21, 2018
As Gizmodo found, many of the responses revolved around removing bad-faith actors, dangerous conspiracists, and white supremacists and neo-Nazis. Still, “it’s unclear if this tweak to the platform is in response to that feedback, given that enabling such groups has been a consistent criticism of Twitter for several years.”
To date, Gizmodo calls Twitter’s enforcement “inconsistent” since “some of the most inflammatory accounts remain discoverable in dropdown searches.”
It continues, “The primary factor distinguishing the accounts searched for by Gizmodo staff, however, is a history of bad-faith engagement that contributes to open hostilities on the platform.”
I’m not sure how I feel about this. On the one hand, characters who claim to be neo-Nazis have no place on Twitter, Facebook, or anywhere else on the internet, and to demote makes sense. However, it seems Twitter is only going after characters it believes are rightwing, even though there are also bad actors on the left side of the spectrum. By doing so, Twitter risks being accused of bias, even though in some instances, their decision to demote some users is justified.
What do you think? Leave your comments below.
For more tech and social news, make sure to check out:
- Zuckerberg seems to suggest Holocaust deniers have a place on Facebook
- We need to talk about the Black Metal Cats Twitter account and how fucking awesome it is
- Some Uber drivers are being accused of committing ‘vomit fraud‘